D I S C R I M I N A T I O N    &    N A T I O N A L    S E C U R I T Y    I N I T I A T I V E    --    B L O G
  DNSI Home - http://pluralism.org/affiliates/kaur_sidhu/
  Pluralism Project - http://www.pluralism.org
  Harvard University - http://www.harvard.edu


Wednesday, June 29, 2005

Judicial Restraint, Internment, and Slavery

Stephen J. Fortunato Jr. offers this very interesting book review of Men In Black: How the Supreme Court Is Destroying America, by Mark R. Levin. Levin argues principally that the Justices of the Supreme Court have neglected or ignored the letter of the law in an effort to codify their own subjective views as to what the appropriate outcome of a given case should be. In other words, "Good judges 'look to the text of the Constitution and the intent of the framers when deciding a constitutional question.' Activist judges, on the other hand, 'see their role limited only by the boundaries of their imaginations,' and 'they substitute their will for the judgment of deliberative bodies.'"

Interestingly, Levin "points to the infamous decisions of Dred Scott upholding slavery and Korematsu allowing the World War II internment of Japanese-Americans as examples of judicial abuse" (emphasis added). In other words, under the regime favored by Levin, an originalist justice would look only to the original intent of the Framers and actual text of the Constitution, and arrive at opposite conclusions from the court in both Dred Scott (slavery) and Korematsu (internment).

Fortunato Jr. effectively rebuts this argument: "Levin fails to grasp that the majorities in both these cases employed the judicial philosophy he advocates, deferring to a congressional enactment in the former case and in the latter to executive orders issued in the name of national security."

Indeed, Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, who authored the Dred Scott opinion, "was personally opposed to slavery, having freed his own slaves" (contra "Dred Scott case: the Supreme Court decision"). In fact, Reverdy Johnson, who represented the slave owner in Dred Scott, was "personally opposed to slavery." In other words, both Taney and Johnson put aside their own personal opinions regarding slavery and followed only the law as they interpreted it - reaching the now universally recognized unjust result of the case. Thus, it appears as if Levin is overly optimistic about the merits of his judicial philosophy, and has incorrectly assumed that an impartial justice would arrive at legal conclusions that he -- and the rest of society -- now agree with.

DNSI     direct link     0 comments   Email post: 



0 Comments:
Post a Comment

<< Home



About DNSI

The Discrimination & National Security Initiative (DNSI) is a research entity that examines the mistreatment of minority communities during times of military action or national crisis.

More Info:
DNSI Home Page




The Blog

Why a Blog?
The purpose of this web-log is to offer news and commentary in a fluid, dynamic format while our more substantive reports are forthcoming.

Recent Posts
Britain's Proposed Ban on Inciting Religious Hatred
SCOTUS - Ten Commandments Decisions
"Muslim man sues Department of Homeland Security"
"Report details secret detentions of US-based Musl...
Action Alert from United Sikhs on Right to Turban ...
"Illinois governor signs hate crime bills"
"Burning Of Koran Investigated As Hate Crime"
"Respect Difference"
NAPALC Issues Action Alert on Hate Crimes Legislation
Million Muslim March?

Archives
04/01/2005 - 05/01/2005
05/01/2005 - 06/01/2005
06/01/2005 - 07/01/2005
07/01/2005 - 08/01/2005
08/01/2005 - 09/01/2005
09/01/2005 - 10/01/2005
10/01/2005 - 11/01/2005
11/01/2005 - 12/01/2005
12/01/2005 - 01/01/2006
01/01/2006 - 02/01/2006
02/01/2006 - 03/01/2006
03/01/2006 - 04/01/2006
04/01/2006 - 05/01/2006
05/01/2006 - 06/01/2006
06/01/2006 - 07/01/2006
07/01/2006 - 08/01/2006
08/01/2006 - 09/01/2006
09/01/2006 - 10/01/2006
10/01/2006 - 11/01/2006
11/01/2006 - 12/01/2006
12/01/2006 - 01/01/2007
01/01/2007 - 02/01/2007
02/01/2007 - 03/01/2007
03/01/2007 - 04/01/2007
04/01/2007 - 05/01/2007
05/01/2007 - 06/01/2007
06/01/2007 - 07/01/2007
07/01/2007 - 08/01/2007
08/01/2007 - 09/01/2007
09/01/2007 - 10/01/2007
10/01/2007 - 11/01/2007
11/01/2007 - 12/01/2007
12/01/2007 - 01/01/2008
01/01/2008 - 02/01/2008
02/01/2008 - 03/01/2008
03/01/2008 - 04/01/2008
04/01/2008 - 05/01/2008
05/01/2008 - 06/01/2008
06/01/2008 - 07/01/2008
07/01/2008 - 08/01/2008
08/01/2008 - 09/01/2008
09/01/2008 - 10/01/2008
10/01/2008 - 11/01/2008
11/01/2008 - 12/01/2008
12/01/2008 - 01/01/2009
01/01/2009 - 02/01/2009


Etc...

Religious Diversity News-Pluralism Project









Blogroll
Into the Whirlwind
Human Rights in India
IntentBlog
Ethnic Confusion Britain
MrSikhNet
Anil Kalhan
Islamicate
Ultrabrown
Sepia Mutiny

Feeds, etc.











(c) 2005 Discrimination & National Security Initiative 1531 Cambridge Street Cambridge, MA 02138